Lesson 4: Conditional support, promoting the will to escape poverty

The National Target Program for Sustainable Poverty Reduction for the 2021-2025 period has many new points compared to the 2016-2020 period. That is, implementing a strategy focusing on people, directly investing in and improving the capacity of the poor; clearly identifying the causes of poverty to fundamentally and thoroughly solve the problems of the poor and the core poor areas. The program's goal is to strive for the poverty rate according to the multidimensional poverty standard to maintain a reduction of 1.0-1.5%/year; the poverty rate of ethnic minority households to decrease by over 3.0%/year...

Chủ tịch UBND tỉnh Nguyễn Đức Trung thăm các mô hình kinh tế tại xã Tam Quang (Tương Dương). Ảnh tư liệu: Phạm Bằng
Chairman of the Provincial People's Committee Nguyen Duc Trung visited economic models in Tam Quang commune (Tuong Duong). Photo: Pham Bang

In Nghe An, the population living in ethnic minority and mountainous areas is over 1.2 million people (accounting for 36% of the province's population). Of which, ethnic minorities are 491,267 people, accounting for 14.76% of the province's population and 40.93% of the population in mountainous areas.

In reality, a part of the people still have the mentality of waiting and relying on others, not making efforts to escape poverty. In addition, people are still hesitant when approaching new things, afraid of change, afraid of risks, not knowing what to raise, what to plant to suit the characteristics of the land and climate of the locality. This mentality greatly limits investment in livelihood development models.

Cán bộ nông nghiệp xã Yên Tĩnh (Tương Dương) hướng dẫn người dân cách thu hái chè dây. Ảnh: P.V
Agricultural staff of Yen Tinh commune (Tuong Duong) instruct people on how to harvest tea vines. Photo: PV

Therefore, the important and urgent solution now is to strengthen propaganda to raise awareness, change the way of thinking and doing for people; encourage poor households to register to escape poverty. In addition, there is an incentive mechanism for pioneering and exemplary households in economic development; self-reliance, self-reliance, and efforts to escape poverty.

Visiting the fruit-laden macadamia garden of Mr. Ha Van Tam's family in Muong Piet village, Thong Thu commune (Que Phong), we could not help but wonder why many places have failed to implement the macadamia planting model, but Mr. Tam's family has been so effective in planting more than 1 hectare with about 350 trees?

Mắc ca đạt sản lượng và chất lượng quả tốt. Ảnh: G.H
Macadamia has good yield and fruit quality. Photo: GH

Through discussion, Mr. Tam said: 8 years ago, by chance, he visited a relative in Dak Lak, saw that the climate and soil were similar to his hometown, so he bought macadamia seeds to try planting. Unexpectedly, the trees grew quickly, and with the adherence to the techniques he learned from his relative and the Macadamia Association in Nghe An, Mr. Tam's macadamia garden developed well, with an average annual harvest of 7-8 billion fruits with a revenue of 70-80 million VND. "Previously, the product was imported to the South, but recently it has been purchased by a factory in Nghia Dan district" - Mr. Tam's wife shared.

Mô hình trồng mắc ca đang được triển khai nhân rộng ở xã Thông Thụ (Quế Phong) vì phù hợp với chất đất và khí hậu. Ảnh: G.H
The macadamia growing model is being widely deployed in Thong Thu commune (Que Phong) because it is suitable for the soil and climate. Photo: GH

According to Mr. Phan Xuan Hung - Deputy Director of the Agricultural Service Center of Que Phong district: The success of Mr. Tam's family shows that macadamia trees are suitable for the climate and soil of Thong Thu area, so the Que Phong district government has paid attention to surveying and assigned the district's Agricultural Service Center to directly guide people on how to care for them, thereby expanding the macadamia gardens in Muong Piet village and neighboring areas. "Currently, 24 households in Thong Thu commune have registered to grow macadamia trees from the national target program's capital, each household is expected to have 0.5 hectares" - Mr. Hung said.

Cây mắc ca trồng 2-3 năm là cho thu hoạch. Ảnh tư liệu: Bá Hậu
Macadamia trees can be harvested after 2-3 years of planting. Photo: Ba Hau

In many localities, Party committees and authorities have taken action to change people's awareness and overcome the mindset of waiting and relying on others; promoting the role of Party members and cadres in propagating and implementing assistance for poor households. In Ky Son district, in addition to taking advantage of support sources from State programs and projects, since 2017, the Standing Committee of the District Party Committee has issued Directive 17/CT-HU for Party members and cadres to help poor households. Since its implementation, through 3 campaigns, 71 organizations and 17 individuals who are heads of Party committees, authorities, agencies and departments have contributed money to buy trees and seedlings to support 345 poor and near-poor families in developing livelihood models. By the end of 2022, 282 households were helped to escape poverty (reaching 81.7%).

Huyện Kỳ Sơn và ngành Nông nghiệp và PTNT  kiểm tra, tìm hướng đi nâng cao giá trị sản phẩm mận Kỳ Sơn. Ảnh: Phú Hương
Ky Son district and the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development inspect and find ways to increase the value of Ky Son plum products. Photo: Phu Huong

In Tuong Duong district, the Standing Committee of the District Party Committee issued Project No. 07-DA/HU on March 8, 2022 on eliminating conservative, expectant, and dependent thinking among cadres, party members, and the masses. The project clearly states that it is necessary to strengthen the effective implementation of setting an example, requiring each party member to be associated with the household responsibility model.

In particular, to overcome the mentality of waiting and relying on "rather suffer than work hard" that still exists among the people, in addition to synchronously implementing support policies according to the Resolution of the National Assembly and the Government to invest in ethnic minority and mountainous areas, Tuong Duong district has directed departments and branches to review and supplement a number of mechanisms and policies that are no longer suitable, from "free" to "conditional" support; focusing on supporting product output, helping to connect product consumption channels, and building product brands.

Mô hình rau sạch ở bản Phòng, thị trấn Thạch Giám (Tương Dương). Ảnh tư liệu: P.V
Clean vegetable model in Phong village, Thach Giam town (Tuong Duong). Photo: PV

The current policy of supporting sustainable poverty reduction livelihood models is “conditional support”, with reciprocal support, promoting the spirit of the State and the people working together. However, according to Mr. Duong Hoang Vu - Chairman of the People's Committee of Que Phong district, for border districts where the poverty rate is still high, to maintain the “3 peaces” (peace for the people, peace for the area, peace for the border), it is necessary to consider the option of taking short-term to support long-term to ensure food security.

Vẻ đẹp non nước sông Giăng và đại ngàn Pù Mát. Ảnh tư liệu: Lê Quang Dũng
The beauty of the Giang River and the Pu Mat forest. Photo: Le Quang Dung

Therefore, in addition to forestry trees and some medicinal plants, many localities have also proactively implemented short-term tree and animal models that can be quickly rotated for high income, focusing on the linkage chain to create output for products. For example, many districts have taken advantage of water surface areas and hydroelectric reservoir areas to develop fish cage farming livelihood models, establishing cooperatives and production linkage groups. Typically, in Tuong Duong district, in 2022, there were over 501 fish cages; the output of fishing and aquaculture reached 595 tons, an increase of 14% compared to 2020. Meanwhile, in Que Phong district, the aquaculture area is constantly expanding, the whole district has 902 fish cages, the output of fishing in the past 2.5 years reached 1,840 tons, bringing a stable source of income for many households.

Mô hình nuôi cá lồng cho thu nhập cao ở xã Thông Thụ (Quế Phong). Ảnh: K.L
Cage fish farming model brings high income in Thong Thu commune (Que Phong). Photo: KL

According to Mr. Nguyen Ho Lam - Deputy Head of the Provincial Rural Development Department: The implementation of projects and models to support production development, diversify livelihoods and replicate poverty reduction models in the period of 2021-2025 needs to focus on 2 main groups. For the crop group, the focus should be on native fruit trees and citrus trees. In the field of livestock, 3 districts 30a focus on breeding cows, fattening cows, native livestock and poultry; the remaining districts invest in Sind crossbred cows and pigs, chickens of all kinds.

Người dân xã Mường Lống (Kỳ Sơn) đẩy mạnh phát triển chăn nuôi gia súc. Ảnh: Gia Huy
People of Muong Long commune (Ky Son) promote livestock farming. Photo: Gia Huy

Because the projects and models supporting production development in the above two groups both meet the requirements of rapidly increasing income and are suitable for customs, practices, and community needs; at the same time, these are products that serve the essential needs of the people, are easily linked in the value chain, and have a consumer market for the products produced; in case of natural disasters and epidemics, they are easy to resist, easy to treat, and have limited losses.

However, to have a sustainable model, livelihood diversification activities must be proposed by the community, in accordance with the customs, practices, and needs of the people, and in accordance with the goals of the National Target Program on Sustainable Poverty Reduction for the 2021-2025 period and legal regulations.

Mô hình sâm bảy lá mang lại giá trị kinh tế cho các hộ dân ở bản Phá Lõm. Ảnh: Gia Huy
The seven-leaf ginseng model brings economic value to households in Pha Lom village. Photo: Gia Huy

According to Mr. Phan Van Manh - Chairman of the Farmers' Association of Ky Son district: In parallel with the implementation of projects, it is necessary to promote the synchronous formation of cooperative models and cooperative groups to connect poor household members, connect with the community and represent connections with businesses. Because the construction of livelihood models of trees and animals still requires the most important value chain from input to output for products.

Regarding this issue, Mr. Tran Quoc Thanh - former Director of the Department of Science and Technology also said: The livelihood development program for the poor must be part of the overall livelihood development and socio-economic development of the entire community in the village, commune, and even in the district and province.

Một số hộ dân ở bản Văng Môn, xã Tam Hợp thành công với mô hình nuôi dê. Ảnh: Gia Huy
Some households in Vang Mon village, Tam Hop commune have succeeded with the goat farming model. Photo: Gia Huy

However, each household has different conditions, circumstances and capacities, so supporting community development also needs a suitable roadmap and cannot be done at the same time and in the same way. This issue requires a systematic, persistent and synchronous implementation at all links of the product value chain, especially requiring the support of the entire political system as well as the social community and businesses.

Giống keo cấp phát cho các hộ trồng rừng được chủ động ngay trên địa bàn huyện Tương Dương. Ảnh: P.V
Acacia seeds are actively distributed to forest planting households in Tuong Duong district. Photo: PV

Nghe An has the largest planned forest area in the country with 1.16 million hectares, accounting for 71.6% of the total area of ​​the province. For generations, people's lives have been closely linked to the forest. On July 18, 2023, the Politburo issued Resolution No. 39 on the construction and development of Nghe An province to 2030 with a vision to 2045, including the criteria: "Developing forests together with the carbon credit market; focusing on developing the production of non-timber forest products, especially medicinal plants"...

According to Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Le Minh Hoan, Resolution No. 39 is a very important document for Nghe An province, however, what is needed now is "we should shift from the mindset of hiring people to protect the forest, to the mindset of the State supporting the creation of livelihoods and jobs under the forest canopy.

Bộ trưởng Bộ Nông nghiệp và Phát triển nông thôn Lê Minh Hoan trao đổi với lãnh đạo xã Tây Sơn (Kỳ Sơn) về phát triển cây pơ mu tại địa phương. Ảnh: Thanh Lê
Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Le Minh Hoan discussed with leaders of Tay Son commune (Ky Son) about developing po mu trees in the locality. Photo: Thanh Le

People who find income there will have the responsibility to protect the forest. Because it is easy to understand, people see that without forests, there will be no more livelihoods under the forest canopy. If we want to have a livelihood, we must join hands to protect the forest, then we will be successful". Agreeing with this point of view, Mr. Nguyen Van Hai - Secretary of Tuong Duong District Party Committee said: Livelihoods for poor households in mountainous areas need to be linked to forests to protect forests and gain benefits from forests.

Cán bộ Kiểm lâm hướng dẫn người dân thời điểm thu hoạch lùng. Ảnh: Đình Tuyên
Forest rangers guide people on when to harvest bamboo. Photo: Dinh Tuyen

At the working session between the working group of the National Assembly's Supervisory Delegation and the People's Committee of Nghe An province regarding the implementation of three national target programs on new rural construction, sustainable poverty reduction and socio-economic development in ethnic minority and mountainous areas in the province taking place in June 2023, Vice Chairman of the Provincial People's Committee Bui Dinh Long raised the issue: Currently, the system of decrees, circulars and instructions of the Government and central ministries and branches for application and implementation is too much; some contents even do not have a legal basis for implementation.

Rừng lùng xanh tốt ở xã Đồng Văn (Quế Phong). Ảnh: Đình Tuyên
Lush green forests in Dong Van commune (Que Phong). Photo: Dinh Tuyen

While Nghe An has 11 mountainous districts and towns and ethnic minority areas; the socio-economic conditions as well as the living standards of the people are still difficult, the mobilization of people's participation in the programs is still limited. On the other hand, the level, capacity of management, direction, operation, and implementation of programs and projects of the staff, especially at the grassroots level, has certain shortcomings. The arrangement of counterpart funds to implement projects, especially in districts and communes of ethnic minorities, is extremely difficult...

Lãnh đạo xã Châu Thắng (Quỳ Châu) khảo sát diện tích lùng trồng tại vườn gia đình chị Vi Thị Hà ở bản Xẹt. Ảnh tư liệu: Nguyên Nguyên
Leaders of Chau Thang commune (Quy Chau) surveyed the area of ​​​​planting trees in the garden of Ms. Vi Thi Ha's family in Xet village. Photo: Nguyen Nguyen

Vice Chairman of the Provincial People's Committee Bui Dinh Long requested the working group to make recommendations to the National Assembly and propose to the Government to direct central ministries and branches to develop specific procedures and methods for implementing national target programs on the basis of integrating decrees, circulars, and instructions, creating favorable conditions for local levels.

Looking at reality, it can be seen that the implementation of programs and projects to support sustainable poverty reduction in general and the development of livelihood models for the poor in particular is a very necessary and humane policy. However, to ensure feasibility, when put into practice, it is necessary to ensure the right subjects, the right purposes, focused investment, creating motivation and opportunities for people to rise out of poverty; avoiding the mentality of waiting and relying on the State's protection.

Cụm dân cư sinh sống tại xã Nậm Giải - thuộc Khu Bảo tồn thiên nhiên Pù Hoạt (Quế Phong). Ảnh: Thành Cường
Residential area in Nam Giai commune - Pu Hoat Nature Reserve (Que Phong). Photo: Thanh Cuong