When the Brexit 'captain' runs out of ideas

After lawmakers rejected the Downing Street boss's second attempt to call an early election to resolve the Brexit impasse, Johnson is now limping towards a crucial EU summit next month, just days before Brexit is scheduled to end.

Failure after failure

On the night of September 9, Mr. Johnson decided to suspend the activities of Parliament. The move came after an unpleasant evening, when his government lost two votes in parliament, "contributing" to the four seats lost last week.

In parallel with rejecting the Prime Minister's move to hold an early general election, the British Parliament earlier this week also forced Johnson's senior aides to disclose private communications on all issues related to the suspension of Parliament.

Boris Johnson is at risk of becoming Britain's shortest-serving prime minister. Photo: AFP

According to some analysts, in the end, this does not affect much the political scene in the foggy country, but it marks another humiliating defeat for a brand new leader.

Last week, lawmakers seized control of the parliamentary process from Mr Johnson’s government, and then passed a bill that would force the prime minister to ask the European Union (EU) for a Brexit extension.

This, in theory, would rule out the possibility of a “hard” Brexit, meaning no deal, on October 31. Finally, among the options put forward in parliament, where Mr Johnson has lost his majority, he has once again tried and failed to call an early election.

According to CNN, the British Prime Minister's suspension of Parliament comes at a crucial time in the Brexit process and has created what has been called "crazy" days in less than a month.

Parliament will return on October 14, after the major parties have held their annual conferences. Three days later, the other 27 EU members will meet for a summit in Brussels, Belgium.

This is where any extension or changes to the Brexit deal, if any, will take place. If Johnson is agreed to give him a new deal – which he has said is his government’s main objective – he will have just two weeks to get it through Parliament.

This option does not seem very promising, because the terms that Mr. Johnson proposed for the new agreement break the “red line” on Brexit that the EU has drawn.

Britain must leave the EU on October 31, whether or not it reaches a divorce deal with Brussels. Photo: AFP

The EU's view that Britain has not yet proposed viable alternatives to the Brexit deal was once again emphasised by Irish leader Leo Varadkar, who told reporters alongside Mr Johnson on 9 September in Dublin:

“We are open to alternatives. But they have to be practical, legally binding and achievable. So far, we have not received any such proposals.”

What scenario for Johnson?

There are three possible scenarios in the current context, but it should be noted that each scenario would lead to chaos and confusion in the capital of London, the land of fog.

First, Prime Minister Johnson could follow the law passed by Parliament last week and request a delay to Brexit. The EU could agree to this request, and a “no deal” scenario could be avoided for the time being. Then, when everyone “takes a breather,” things will get complicated.

The EU, and France in particular, have made it clear that a third extension will only be granted if there are fundamental changes in the UK's political calculus.

In practice, radical change would mean holding an election, something the opposition would be less likely to object to at that stage, when a hard Brexit is temporarily off the table.

But this also means that an extension will only be approved on the condition that an election is certain to take place.

The second option would see the EU reject Johnson’s request for an extension. He would return to London facing a choice: revive former Prime Minister Theresa May’s thrice-defeated Brexit deal or accept no-deal as the default.

This would lead to two weeks of chaos, as the opposition seeks to force a general election by calling a vote of no confidence in Mr Johnson's government.

The third option is similar to the second, but with a bit more legal complexity. If Johnson refuses to extend his mandate, he would be ignoring a legal requirement. He could then face impeachment or, worse, imprisonment.

CNN commented that there is no doubt that this level of "designed" chaos, which will gradually decrease as the Brexit deadline of October 31 approaches, is a deliberate move by the British government.

EU leaders have accused Johnson's government of failing to come up with concrete alternative Brexit plans. Photo: AFP

Mr Johnson's close advisers have made no secret of their belief that the British Parliament is actively ignoring the will of the people on Brexit and is only interested in engaging in debates with the public.

Johnson wants an early election because he believes his “do-or-die” Brexit plan will give him a majority in Parliament. That is why he is trying to get the vote through Parliament on the night of 9 September.

Now that his request has been rejected, Johnson finds himself with little choice. Caught in a legal and constitutional web, the British Prime Minister has suspended Parliament and withdrawn support for his opponents, stripping them of the last thing he has power over – parliamentary time.

It was a risky move, but desperate times call for extreme measures. And if Johnson’s last resort fails, there may be only one move left for the leader: recalling Parliament and calling for a vote of confidence in himself.