Receiving a lump-sum social insurance benefit - A trade-off?

Dinh Vien• June 18, 2018 08:06

Many workers view receiving a one-time severance payment as a way to solve immediate difficulties, overlooking long-term benefits.

According to Vietnam Social Security, the number of workers receiving one-time social insurance benefits is currently on the rise. In the first five months of 2018, nearly 300,000 workers nationwide received one-time benefits from Vietnam Social Security. Statistics show that in recent years, an average of about 700,000 people annually apply for one-time social insurance benefits.

Accepting the trade-off?

According to a survey by the Institute of Trade Union Workers (Vietnam General Confederation of Labor), the majority of workers who resign and receive a lump-sum social insurance benefit are aged 35-40, mainly working in labor-intensive enterprises such as textiles, footwear, and seafood. Explaining this phenomenon, Mr. Le Dinh Quang, Deputy Head of the Labor Relations Department of the Vietnam General Confederation of Labor, said that most older workers, with declining health and low productivity, fear being dismissed by their employers, so resigning to receive a lump-sum social insurance benefit is their only option.

Receiving a lump-sum benefit will leave workers in financial difficulty in their old age.

Speaking to us, Mr. Nguyen Van Le, human resources director of a company specializing in processing leather shoes for export in Binh Duong province, said that recently, many workers who have been with the company for 15 to under 19 years have been continuously submitting resignation letters to receive a lump-sum social insurance payment.

"The company has no policy of laying off older workers, so the HR department tried to persuade them to withdraw their decision, as it would affect their long-term future, but they remained stubborn. Receiving a substantial severance payment but not knowing how to use it will certainly leave them with an uncertain future," Mr. Le expressed his concern.

Regarding the reason for resigning, Ms. Tran Thi Kim Dam, originally from Tien Giang province and a worker at a company in Cu Chi district, Ho Chi Minh City, said that she had been working at the company since 1998, for 20 years. At the age of 40, she felt she no longer had the health to continue working as a factory worker. Ms. Dam said:"I want to quit my job early so that in addition to unemployment insurance and severance pay, I can also receive a lump-sum social insurance payment. Gathering all the benefits will give me some capital to start a business." When we asked if she was worried about her future in old age without a pension, Ms. Dam smiled dismissively: "Whatever happens, happens. Why think so far ahead?"

For the same reason, despite working for nearly 19 years, worker Ho Thi Tot (from Long An province), currently working at a company in Binh Duong, also decided to quit her job to receive a one-time social insurance benefit. "Because of my age, I can't keep up with younger workers, my productivity is very low, and sooner or later I'll lose my job. By submitting my resignation, I'll get a decent amount of money to go back to my hometown and start a business," Ms. Tot explained.

Anxiety about the future is a common sentiment among older workers, so resigning to receive a lump-sum social insurance benefit is perhaps only a temporary solution. Losing their jobs at an advanced age certainly means their chances of returning to the labor market are very low.

A bleak future

According to the 2014 Social Insurance Law, in addition to the provisions on pension benefits, employees may also receive a lump-sum social insurance payment. However, if employees do not carefully consider their options before deciding whether to receive a lump-sum payment or a pension, they may be at a disadvantage.

According to labor experts, employees themselves need to think carefully before deciding to receive a lump-sum social insurance payment, because if they do, they will lose the opportunity to receive a pension, there will be no guarantee for their lives in old age, and they will become a burden on their families and society.

According to lawyer Dang Anh Duc (Dang & Associates Law Firm - Hanoi Bar Association), employees need to understand that the money contributed to the social insurance fund is their valuable savings; it is not lost but is instead managed and invested for growth by the social insurance agency. Employees can completely preserve their social insurance contribution period so that when conditions permit, they can continue to participate in mandatory social insurance or participate in voluntary social insurance with partial financial support from the state.

"During the period of leave of absence, if the employee unfortunately passes away, they will receive a funeral allowance equal to 10 months of the basic salary. Depending on the circumstances, dependents may receive a monthly survivor's benefit (maximum 4 people) until they reach adulthood (if they are children) or until death (if they are spouses or parents who have reached retirement age and have no income or have income lower than the basic salary). In the case of receiving a lump-sum survivor's benefit, the amount is calculated as a lump-sum social insurance payment. With these benefits, employees must carefully consider their options to secure their future," advises lawyer Duc.

Agreeing with this opinion, Mr. Nguyen Van Khai, Permanent Vice Chairman of the Ho Chi Minh City Labor Union, analyzed: "If workers receive a lump-sum social insurance payment, they will suffer a great disadvantage. With a contribution rate of 22% of monthly salary to the retirement and death benefit fund, the total annual contribution is 2.64 months' salary, while the lump-sum social insurance benefit for each year of contribution is only 2 months' salary. Thus, workers lose 0.64 months' salary."

Short-term gains, long-term losses.

One of the reasons why workers prefer a lump-sum social insurance benefit is the overly simple eligibility requirements; specifically, they only need to quit their jobs for one year without continuing to participate in social insurance to be eligible. Furthermore, the relatively long minimum social insurance contribution period (20 years) required to receive a pension has discouraged some workers.

"To mitigate this situation, trade unions at all levels must focus on disseminating information and explaining to workers the harmful effects of receiving a lump-sum social insurance benefit, urging them not to sacrifice long-term benefits for short-term gains. In addition, the Social Insurance Law needs to be reviewed to shorten the minimum social insurance contribution period required to receive a pension, and increase state support for voluntary social insurance participants… so that workers can see the practical benefits of accumulating social insurance contributions to receive a pension," suggested Mr. Le Dinh Quang.

Source: nld.com.vn
Copy Link
0 0 0
x
Receiving a lump-sum social insurance benefit - A trade-off?
Google News
POWERED BYFREECMS- A PRODUCT OFNEKO